His concerned voice always reminded me of the twenty-eight-year-old him.

“I’m not sure yet. Do you… want me to stay close to you?”

Ryan thought for a moment before replying.

“Of course. If you’re too far away, who’s going to help me chase after Emily?”

His words hit me like a bucket of cold water, soaking me through.

My smile froze.

“Ryan, if I were to leave—”

Before I could finish, Ryan cut me off.

“Claire, Emily’s calling me. I’ll hang up first. See you at the graduation party tonight.”

The call ended, and I was used to it by now.

I had spent over six years in this world with Ryan, yet almost every time, his first choice was always Emily Carter.

At twenty-eight, I could never understand how someone could remain so devoted in marriage, love unchanged after eight years.

Now I realized—it was because he had once met someone truly dazzling in his youth.

And unfortunately, I had merely become her substitute, nothing more.

Scrolling through Ryan’s social media posts, those hidden from Emily’s view:

“Seems like I’ve fallen a little more in love again.”

“Emily, even though you can’t see this, I still want to say—I really like you.”

“Emily, I’ll grow up faster, so I can give you a home.”