Carol answered on the fourth ring, breathless in the performative way that suggests a person wants you to know you are interrupting a very full and important life. In the background I could hear a television and, faintly, Melissa’s laugh. So they were together still. Of course they were. Probably debriefing the day, already flattening it into a version where I had embarrassed everyone by “making something out of nothing.”

“Hey, honey,” Carol said. “Everything okay?”

Daniel looked at me once, then away.

“No,” he said. “It’s not.”

What followed was not elegant. Real confrontations rarely are. He stumbled. He circled. He started with chair shortage and hurt feelings and disrespect, and I could practically hear Carol seizing on every soft word as proof there was room to maneuver.

“Oh, for heaven’s sake,” she said at one point, loud enough for me to hear from across the table. “The children were fine. Melissa already said there weren’t enough seats.”

“There were chairs in the house,” Daniel replied, stronger now.

“That is not the point.”