Karen folded her arms. “The truth is your wife is unstable.”

A laugh rose in my throat. It sounded like metal tearing.

“No. The truth is I came home and found my pregnant wife scrubbing her skin raw while you sat in my chair eating fruit.”

“She needed correction!” Karen snapped.

I looked at my mother.

And suddenly, I saw everything clearly.

“You hired her,” I said.

My mother stiffened. “Excuse me?”

“You pushed for her. You said Emily needed someone older. Firm. Experienced.” I stepped closer. “What exactly did you hire her to do?”

“Daniel, you’re being ridiculous.”

But Karen’s silence answered for her.

Memories crashed over me. Emily apologizing for dropping a spoon. Emily asking if I would leave her if pregnancy made her difficult. Emily flinching when cabinets slammed. Emily telling me Karen “meant well” in the empty voice of someone repeating a line she had been trained to say.

I had seen all the signs.

And I had dismissed them as stress.

The shame nearly made me sick.

“She’s been whispering to you,” my mother said suddenly. “That girl has always been manipulative. Women from backgrounds like hers know how to cling. They weaponize helplessness.”