Brooke rolled her eyes. “Because Noah ruined everything.”

“He was four,” Ava whispered.

The sentence hung in the room like an accusation.

I remembered leaving for Dubai with a thousand calculations in my head and one promise at the center of all of them: five years, maybe less, and I would come home with enough money that Ava would never have to worry about bills again and Noah would never hear the word no for the wrong reasons. I remembered wiring eight thousand dollars a month to my mother because she already handled the family account and said she would move the money wherever Ava needed it.

I was not sending money to a caretaker.

I was financing my own family’s captivity.

“Did you have a phone?” I asked Ava.

“At first.”

“What happened to it?”

My mother answered before she could. “She lost it.”

Ava closed her eyes.

Brooke muttered, “Or sold it.”

I leaned both hands on the table. “Ava.”

She looked up again, and whatever she saw in my face gave her something she apparently had not been allowed for years.

Permission.